NewIdeaFood
  • News
  • Dinner Tonight
  • Baking
  • Trolley Watch
  • Easy Entertaining
  • Healthy-ish
  • Video
NewIdeaFood
  • News
  • Dinner Tonight
  • Baking
  • Trolley Watch
  • Easy Entertaining
  • Healthy-ish
  • Video
ALDI - DON'T DROWN IN ONE-OFF DISCOUNTS!
Watch 0:15

ALDI - DON'T DROWN IN ONE-OFF DISCOUNTS!

{headline}

{headline}

Tablespoon to mL: How many mL in a tablespoon?

Tablespoon to mL: How many mL in a tablespoon?

10 of the best egg substitutes for cooking and baking

10 of the best egg substitutes for cooking and baking

8 Substitutes for Sunflower Oil

8 Substitutes for Sunflower Oil

What is Confectioners Sugar? Everything You Need to Know

What is Confectioners Sugar? Everything You Need to Know

{headline}

{headline}

What Is Cake Flour In Australia? Best Substitutes & Replacements

What Is Cake Flour In Australia? Best Substitutes & Replacements

Honey vs Sugar: Everything You Need To Know

Honey vs Sugar: Everything You Need To Know

What is vanilla bean powder?

What is vanilla bean powder?

{headline}

{headline}

How many grams in a tablespoon? Convert grams to tablespoons

How many grams in a tablespoon? Convert grams to tablespoons

50 of Our Most Popular Cakes of All Time

50 of Our Most Popular Cakes of All Time

Grams to Cups: How Many Grams in a Cup?

Grams to Cups: How Many Grams in a Cup?

What Is the Difference Between Macaron and Macaroon?

What Is the Difference Between Macaron and Macaroon?

The 6 best substitutes for canola oil

The 6 best substitutes for canola oil

Baking soda, baking powder, bicarb soda: what’s the difference?

Baking soda, baking powder, bicarb soda: what’s the difference?

5 of the best palm sugar substitutes

5 of the best palm sugar substitutes

  1. Home
  2. News

8 molasses substitutes and alternatives

How to add a dose sweetness without molasses - by Lottie Dalziel
  • 08 Apr 2019
8 molasses substitutes and alternatives

In Australian dishes molasses is often the dark horse, literally, its rich black consistency is an ingredient in many baking dishes in particular. Molasses also known as black treacle is the result of refining sugarcane into a liquid sugar form. The colour and sweetness vary depending on which phase it is taken from.

It is healthier than traditional white sugars and is often used in baking, cookies and sweet desserts. Out of molasses? Never fear here are eight of the best substitutes.

Types of Molasses

Light molasses has been boiled just once and is the sweetest variety.

Dark molasses has been boiled twice, it is less sweet and has a stronger flavour than light molasses.

Blackstrap molasses has been cooked for the longest, it has a more tart flavour is one of the richer molasses varieties, loaded with iron and calcium it appears very dark.

Pomegranate molasses is the pomegranate juice that has been reduced down without sugar to form a rich syrup.

Where to buy molasses?

Out of molasses or never heard of it before? You can grab it from most supermarkets like Coles and Woolworths.

molasses
$3.5

Mountain Valley Pure & Natural Molasses 500g

Shop

8. White sugar

White sugar

As a last resort yes you can substitute white sugar for molasses. To do so stir together ¼ cup of water with ¾ cup of sugar until a think syrup forms.

Best in: cookies

Recipe suggestion: Mocha Pavlova

Mocha pavlova

7. Golden Syrup

Golden Syrup

Yes, golden syrup can be subbed in for molasses in most recipes, although it will result in a very different flavour. Golden syrups flavour is much lighter and can be swapped in cup for cup.

Best used in: gingerbread or cookies.

Recipe suggestion: Baked golden syrup pudding

Golden syrup

6. Honey

Honey
Getty Images

Honey is just about the next best thing when it comes to a molasses alternative. Its thick liquid consistency is similar to molasses and its taste is consistently sweet in comparison to molasses which can vary depending on variety. Swap in the honey cup for cup.

Best used in: cookies

5. Palm Sugar

Palm sugar

Most commonly used in Asian cooking, plam sugar is a great alternative to molasses in recipes that aren’t looking for stickiness. It is available in both liquid and crystal form and works best in those more savoury dishes.

Best used in: savoury dishes

4. Maple Syrup

Map
Getty Images

Although it isn’t as dark as molasses maple syrup can be easily substituted in recipes. It will give the dish a lighter flavour and golden colour. It is also relatively healthy, it contains fifteen times more calcium to honey.

Best used in: pancakes, porridge

3. Muscovado sugar

Muscovado

In its dense crystal form muscovado sugar is a great swap for molasses. It’s dark brown colouring offers a seamless swap in baking dishes although its flavour is sweeter

2. Brown rice syrup

Brown rice syrup

Brown rice syrup makes for a great molasses substitute, be wary though you’ll need to double the amount of brown rice syrup in the recipe so you might need to reduce the other liquids on the ingredients list.

 

Best used in: biscuits

1. Barley Malt Syrup

Barley malt syrup can be subbed in for molasses in most recipes although it isn’t as sweet if you’re after a sugar hit you’ll need 1 cup of barley malt to every ⅔ cup of molasses.

Best used in: slices and cakes

Lottie Dalziel
Lottie Dalziel
Lottie Dalziel, is a 4AM riser and coffee-addict who lives and breathes all things food. When she isn't reading up on the latest trends in sustainability or discovering ways to upcycle almost anything, you can find her by the beach, cooking up a storm or adding to her abundant (some would say out of control) plant collection.

Subscribe to New Idea-$12 for your first 12 issues!

Subscribe Now
Subscribe to New Idea

Subscribe to New Idea-$12 for your first 12 issues!

Subscribe Now
Subscribe to New Idea

Recommended to you

ALDI - DON'T DROWN IN ONE-OFF DISCOUNTS!
Watch 0:15

ALDI - DON'T DROWN IN ONE-OFF DISCOUNTS!

{headline}

{headline}

Tablespoon to mL: How many mL in a tablespoon?

Tablespoon to mL: How many mL in a tablespoon?

10 of the best egg substitutes for cooking and baking

10 of the best egg substitutes for cooking and baking

8 Substitutes for Sunflower Oil

8 Substitutes for Sunflower Oil

What is Confectioners Sugar? Everything You Need to Know

What is Confectioners Sugar? Everything You Need to Know

{headline}

{headline}

What Is Cake Flour In Australia? Best Substitutes & Replacements

What Is Cake Flour In Australia? Best Substitutes & Replacements

Honey vs Sugar: Everything You Need To Know

Honey vs Sugar: Everything You Need To Know

What is vanilla bean powder?

What is vanilla bean powder?

{headline}

{headline}

How many grams in a tablespoon? Convert grams to tablespoons

How many grams in a tablespoon? Convert grams to tablespoons

50 of Our Most Popular Cakes of All Time

50 of Our Most Popular Cakes of All Time

Grams to Cups: How Many Grams in a Cup?

Grams to Cups: How Many Grams in a Cup?

What Is the Difference Between Macaron and Macaroon?

What Is the Difference Between Macaron and Macaroon?

The 6 best substitutes for canola oil

The 6 best substitutes for canola oil

Baking soda, baking powder, bicarb soda: what’s the difference?

Baking soda, baking powder, bicarb soda: what’s the difference?

5 of the best palm sugar substitutes

5 of the best palm sugar substitutes

NewIdeaFood
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Dietary info
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Dietary info
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Brands

  • New Idea
  • Better Homes and Gardens
  • Better Homes and Gardens Shop
  • All Recipes
  • Practical Parenting

Our Network

  • marie claire
  • Beauty Crew
  • Who
  • Women's Weekly Food
  • Bounty Parents
  • Girlfriend
  • That’s Life
  • Home Beautiful
  • 7plus
  • 7News
  • Health Engine
  • Starts at 60
  • The West Australian
  • Perth Now
  • Airtasker
  • Society One
© 2021 Are Media PTY LTD
Get more from New Idea Food

Magazine Subscription Offer

Subscribe to New Idea-$12 for your first 12 issues!

Shop This Offer
Subscribe to New Idea