Posting her find on the Coles Little Shop & Stikeez Collectables - Buy, Swap, Sell & Freebies Facebook page, one fan shared pics of her rare Silver Buster Burger - complete with what appears to be a male appendage.
What are the rarest Stikeez? Find out here.
Says collector Cam: ‘Guys just wanted to get your opinion, I got this stikee today and on the front, it seems like it’s got a very odd deformity and the back has some sort of thumbprint. Did anyone else get anything with these odd flaws??’
It wasn’t long before the jokes started rolling in.
‘Someone cocked up,’ laughed one. Added another: ‘He he odd penis looking shape in just the right height lol!’
Cam agreed, saying: ‘Someone in the factory has a sense of humour!’
Other collectors suggested that Cam keep the rare and unique Stikeez as it may be worth a bit of money one day.
‘Could well be worth more 👍 it's a keeper 😊,’ said a fan.
New Idea Food has reached out to Coles for comment.